Customer Reviews:
Showing reviews 131-135 of 155
 Outdated, harsh methods October 1, 1999
19 out of 30 found this review helpful
This book is showing its years. Modern methods are much kinder and MORE efficient. Some of the discipline methods contained in this book could make a dog fearful and neurotic. It has some good points but beginners to dog training should be wary of it
 Still the best of all dog books after two decades in print. September 19, 1999
152 out of 171 found this review helpful
My wife and I first used this book in 1980 with our first German Shepherd, a beautiful, gentle and easy to train dog despite strong alpha characteristics. We've given away many copies because it is about so much more than training. The monks have worked with each of our German Shepherds but their approach works with other breeds. Yes, there is a section on physical discipline but there is also a stern caution. This book deserves to read as a whole. We've read it and re-read it over the years, most recently on the death last week at 14 of a great, sensitive and intelligent old girl who was a loyal companion every day of her life. We used the monks excellent puppy book with our other dog, an aging male GSD, and soon it will be time for it again as another companion enters our home. Monks? Dogs? Religion? Don't worry about it. There's nothing to offend anyone. New Skete takes its religious life very seriously, but they are not intrusive. On the other hand, if you drink beer but won't drink the best beer in Belgium because Trappist monks brew it, then you probably won't buy this book and don't deserve a great dog anyway.
Timeless advice from those with in-depth understanding. August 14, 1999
25 out of 29 found this review helpful
If more people would practice the principles contained within this tome, fewer dogs would find themselves in shelters and rescue situations. Wonderful insights presented with captivating writing make this book an invaluable tool for those who truly care about dogs. A copy of The Art of Raising a Puppy, Also by the Monks of New Skeet, will accompany each puppy I place in a new home. Being familiar with and utilizing "clicker" and other techniques based on positive reinforcement, I find this book in no way diminishes the value of positive training. Quite to the contrary, it emphasizes the importance of building a solid trusting, relationship with your dog toward greater mutual fulfillment. Don't hesitate! Add this one to your collection!
 Too traditional -- some bad mixed with the good August 11, 1999
11 out of 16 found this review helpful
Are you interested in training with positive methods? Then skip this book! The monks rely too heavily on outdated methods of discipline. Alpha rolls? Scruff shakes? Sorry, but these techniques are terrifying to dogs, potentially dangerous to trainers, and unnecessary. Yes, there are some great points, but there's no way I'd recommend this book to anyone.
Great Book! June 12, 1999
3 out of 5 found this review helpful
Before I got this book, my dog, Casper, would tear up everything and attack people. Until I got this book and learned to get personal with him. Now he is an angle. This book is a must have!
|
